The Five Creepiest Utah Cemeteries

The Five Creepiest Utah Cemeteries. I grew up in the Avenues here in Salt Lake City, just a couple of blocks from the venerable city cemetery. So we played hide and seek around the tombstones, ran circles around Emo’s Grave and dared the night watchman to chase us down after hours. I didn’t get the full respect and fear for the resting places of the dead until I went on a ghost hunt at the Mercur Cemetery in my teens.


ghost hunting

(photo credit: Andy Wilkes)

Speaking of ghost hunting…

Ghost Hunt Etiquette:

  • Many areas are private property, without getting permission, you run the risk of trespassing.
  • Do some research on the spooky spot first, so you’ll have a better idea of where the phenomenon comes from.
  • Double-check all your recording sources afterward, many things are picked up on tape that can’t be heard live.
  • Be respectful: don’t trample on gravestones, stir up sod, disturb flower arrangements, etc.

Now that we’re entering the crisp days of fall and our thoughts turn to all things creepy, it’s the perfect time to explore some truly terrifying spots here in our Pretty, Great State.


BTW: Still looking for some super creepy spots? Check out our “Utah’s 5 most haunted spots” here, and “5 Utah ghost towns you simply must explore” here.

We’re here for you, honey. Right up to the point of taking care of your therapy bills afterward. That’s your problem.


The Five Creepiest Utah Cemeteries


(photo credit: Niki Chan)

1. Mercur Cemetery:

The mining town of Mercur started in the 1870s, but it was a disastrous fire in 1902 that destroyed the entire town. The graveyard stubbornly persists, though no one’s been buried there since 1913. Picket fences surround 20 of the graves–but walk carefully, you’ll stumble over random tombstones if you’re not watching the uneven ground. Ghost hunters report seeing phantasmagoric flames rising from the graveyard and when taking pictures, terrifying faces would suddenly appear in front of the lens. Close enough to touch. EEEEEEEEEEE!



(photo credit: Norm Thomas)

2. Pleasant Green Cemetery:

I find nothing “pleasant” about watching tombstones glow when a train passes by, but those of us screeching like a barn owl that night certainly witnessed the phenomenon. Pleasant Green’s graveyard was established in 1883, perched on a hill over Magna. The grave of “Sarah J” is often photographed with disturbed earth–like something is trying to dig out–not in.



3. Salt Lake City Cemetery:

I have decades-worth of stories about the scariness of this place – where to begin? Emo’s Grave is likely the most famous – run around the grave 3 times chanting “Emo, Emo, Emo!” and the scary old phantasm is supposed to leave his urn and chase you. There’s all kinds of creepy, crumbling tombs that look uncomfortably open and accessible. But the spot that scares ghost hunters the most has to be Lilly Gray’s tombstone: where her grieving husband had carved “Victim of the Beast 666.” Legend states poor Lilly was the victim of demonic possession. All I can tell you is that the sod around her grave can suddenly turn spongy and soft where you’re standing, winds blow up from nowhere and wordless howling will send you screaming out of the cemetery.



(photo credit: Scott Law)

4. Ephraim Pioneer Cemetery:

This graveyard wasn’t really intended to exist – a settler in Fort Ephraim passed away and was set to be buried in the nearby Allred Settlement. But after a warning of an Indian attack, pioneers hastily buried the man just outside the walls. He was joined by dozens more, including several children who died in an Indian massacre. Sad little voices will ask you to “take me home!” and the wails of mourning parents echo through the tombstones.


the weeping woman

(photo credit: Holly Murdock)

5. Logan Cemetery:

Wait for the night of a full moon and watch tears pour down the face of The Weeping Woman. There’s scores of soldiers buried here, and there’s sounds of battle, shouts and screams that rise from nowhere to a deafening roar, then suddenly stop.

(cover image credit: Pixabay)

So, do you have a favorite “final resting place” to explore? Have you seen anything? Please, share! We’ll post your photos and stories too.


Talking Ghost Hunting With Tom Carr In Utah’s Most Haunted Spot


There’s something so creepy about hanging out with Utah’s most experienced ghost hunter in a graveyard … especially when his eyes are looking at something BEHIND you when you’re chatting. Tom Carr (“Talking to Yourself in the Dark: a Guide to the Paranormal”) tells his most terrifying encounters, his top three spooky spots you should be haunting this weekend and the tools of the trade. (Yes, there really is such a thing as a ghost meter.) And if you’re interested, it looks like he might be guiding us on a ghost hunt sometime soon. Who’s interested?

The Cool New Thing In The Foodie World: Fermentation Cooking – 4.19.19

The Cool New Thing In The Foodie World: Fermentation Cooking. So apparently the Cool New Thing in the Foodie World is… fermentation. Fermentation Cooking. You heard me. So let’s try it together, shall we? First up, your DIY video on sauerkraut.


BTW: you love the whole “bar food thing?” How lucky that the Todd has a tasty pickled egg recipe- you can find it here. It’s right after Easter and I know you have a lot of hard-boiled eggs just sitting around. Staring at you…


It’s sometimes easy to underestimate how far back our history stretches along the Wasatch Front. We live by the beautiful old Salt Lake City Cemetery – yes, where I introduced you to the “Lily Gray 666 Victim of the Beast” tombstone – anyway, all the streets are lined with these glorious old trees. Unfortunately, they’re forced to cut several of them down. But you’ll be stunned to see how long they’ve been there. Find our whole history in the rings of this tree…

How Many Times Can You Remake A Movie Before It’s Just Ridiculous? – 11.12.18

How Many Times Can You Remake A Movie Before It’s Just Ridiculous? So, we dragged the kiddos to a new movie over the weekend… and it begs the question: how many times can you remake the same movie before it’s utterly ridiculous? Let’s discuss. Also, a gorgeous tribute for Veteran’s Day- in the form of a tree stump. And the most beautiful photo series that could change the life of children hoping to be adopted. (image credit: Universal Pictures Australia)

150 Years Of History In A Tree Stump – 11.9.18

150 Years Of History In A Tree Stump. So, the Todd was walking through the old SLC Cemetery and discovered something amazing- 150 years of history in the rings of a tree stump. And on Veteran’s Day weekend, it’s an emotional reminder of how far we’ve come- and how many we’ve lost. Have a look…

Welcome to the Spookiest Spots Along The Wasatch Front – Halloween, 10.31.18

Welcome to the Spookiest Spots Along The Wasatch Front. From Gilgal’s Garden to Emo’s Grave, we scout out your more terrifying places to chill this Halloween, chill? Get it? HAH!


Seriously, sweet little Salt Lake City’s just full of creepy spots. I grew up by the Salt Lake Cemetery, and locals still shiver over the sad tale of the Lily Gray, whose tombstone reads “Victim of the Beast 666.” Why? WHY? We’ll tell you the sordid tale, along with the mysteries of the Iron Cross perched high on the hill above Salt Lake. Or the eerie Pioneer Lime Kiln. And Erin’s true story about what happened to her and three friends on an idiotic and ill-advised adventure at the Salt Lake Crematorium.


Still in the mood for more ghost hunting? Check out the 5 Scariest Ghost Towns in Utah and Utah’s 5 Most Haunted Spots for a guaranteed scare for those time-challenged ghost hunters.